Recent Posts
-
Whither Modern Life?
June 27, 2025
-
What the Hell
June 18, 2025
-
As Darkness Engulfs Us
April 6, 2025
-
AI, Risk, and Work
January 17, 2025
-
“Things Are in the Saddle, and Ride Mankind”
December 29, 2024
-
Forgotten Futures in Seattle
December 12, 2024
-
Autocracy Defeats Neoliberalism
November 14, 2024
-
History… We’re Soaking in It!
October 2, 2024
-
A Numbing Spectacle
September 22, 2024
-
War Is the Air We Breathe
July 15, 2024
|
Great white herons soar among stained highrises, landing on mudflats to compete with vultures for the endless decay of a city that is always helplessly resisting humidification and flooding. At the edge of a forest of such breadth and density, the bird life in Belem is more than North American cities, but perhaps not as much as I’d expect, given the near surroundings. Small parakeets squawk incessantly in the ubiquitous mango trees, strange scruffy dove-like birds with very long tails sail from tree to tree, but not in great numbers. Yellow-bellied sparrows flit about in the Beaux Artes park squares, immaculately prepared for the thousands of guests that have descended on Belem. The sky itself is a grand partner in the panaromic welcome, taking the water from the vast basin beneath it to paint in colors and shapes that take your breath away with their vitality and intricacy.
The city of Belem is hosting the 9th World Social Forum (and 5th Pan-Amazon Social Forum to boot) as the self-proclaimed capital of Pan-Amazonia. It’s actually at the mouth of the Amazon river system in the Brazilian state of Pará, one of several states encompassing the continent-sized region, and that’s only the Brazilian part; according to the WSF declaration, this gathering is hosted by all the countries of Pan-Amazonia: Brazil, Bolivia, Colombia, Ecuador, French Guyana, Peru, Guyana Cooperative Republic, Surinam and Venezuela. Yep, size matters down here, and this is a small city in a very large area. I arrived two days before the beginning and it gave me some hours to acclimatize myself, both to the humidity and rain, and to the lovely sound of Portuguese (almost got it 20 years ago, now I can understand a smattering, quite useful but far from real comprehension). Most of the city was paved at one time, so though the water has relentlessly dug channels and sinkholes along every curb, sometimes precariously deep, it’s not as muddy or dusty is it might be. (This is an impossible town for independent wheelchair users!) Locals are very welcoming, happy to have visitors from afar (and plenty expect to enjoy the economic bounce we bring too), and proud to be the host city for an auspicious international gathering. On a bus ride from the center to the campus of the Federal University a charming woman sat next to me. Detecting that I could understand some of what she was saying, off she went, with recommendations for various beaches and places to eat, but I’m afraid I got only the most barebones idea of what she was telling me. Still, the spirit was great, and it made me happy that I could at least follow it a bit, responding appropriately a couple of times in my less-than-broken Portuguese.
My colleagues Kathy Wallerstein and Andrej Grubacic arrived last night and we went to the Praça da Republica for pizza and beer, meeting Andrej’s old friend Pablo, who turns out to be great pals with my Critical Mass co-conspirator from Sao Paolo Thiago (who also set us up with an apartment so we didn’t have to fight for a hotel). The weirdly moderne restaurant, where the waiters carefully serve the slices of pizza for you, was also the meeting spot of the Amazon activists whom I’d met at the Manaus airport. They were plotting an aerial SOS photoshoot for this morning, but as I guessed, we weren’t up in time to make it out to the campus where it was being staged. Instead, we’ll join the big opening march this afternoon. Word is that Lula, Evo Morales, and Hugo Chavez are all here to host the Forum! Not sure, but that’s the rumor, and it’s a bit embarrassing for those who remember the early days of the World Social Forum, when it was such an oppositional and energetic gathering, full of anti-institutional thinking and plotting. Now, frankly, it’s become rather staid, going by the program, a 150-page newspaper with endless listings in 8 pt type of various panels and discussions. It’s completely unwieldy, but worse, it’s also inaccurate. Of all the folks I’ve spoken with so far, hardly anyone has found their events listed in the catalog (including me”¦ at least Pablo, whom I met last night, knew I was going to be in a discussion with bicyclists from Sao Paolo” [p.s. I met them at the last minute as I was leaving the march yesterday evening and we’re on for 3 pm Friday” yay!]).
 Downtown is not exempt from the relentless moisture reclaiming what it can.
My pal Jeff Conant and his colleague Marcella from Cochabamba, Bolivia, are here with the Red Vida (“Life network”) which is focused on water-as-commons, and they found their full day of panels and workshops to have been reduced to two listings on the errata sheet that helpfully appeared yesterday morning. Jeff’s book, “The Community Guide to Environmental Health,” is available online here, and is well worth a look. All the nuts and bolts of converting your community, whether rural or urban, to a thorough-going sustainability, and remarkably, every part of it has been field tested in at least five different countries and settings. The list of contributors is enormous. At a glance, I’d say this book is a great example of the kind of on-the-ground shift in sensibility that I’ve been talking about for a while with Nowtopia. We’re living through an epistemological shift towards a more integrated world view, where average folks understand on a deep level that we’re having to change how we live, and increasingly, the skills and knowledge that are required to pull that off are being broadly disseminated across the planet.
I mentioned in the previous entry’s comments that the bombing of Gaza has had quite an impact on a lot folks here. It came up quickly when I was waiting to change money at the bank in conversation with the South Africans, and later, I was watching the big TV channel here, O Globo, and they spent a full half hour on a mini-documentary on the effects of the bombing on people in hospitals, neighborhoods, and more, and showed white phosphorous smoldering and flaming on the ground, un-extinguishable by stamping on it. The TV reportage was such a contrast to what we see in the U.S., with reporters going right into the rubble, interviewing victims and survivors, none of whom were combatants or Hamas militants. The basic humanitarianism of the framing was quite direct, and puts the U.S. media to shame (not that it hasn’t long been a pathetic simulacra of “real news” anyway). Anyway, the two South Africans I chatted with were surprised that Americans were so jubilant and hopeful about Obama, since they saw him clearly as the latest “soft face of capitalism” and very much a product of and servant to the ruling class. Perhaps they’re not so easily taken in by the idea that his race is equivalent to real change. (I heard a horrifying anecdote: thousands of white people in DC at the inauguration wearing buttons that said “I [heart] black people”!!?? ack! Can this be true? If it is, how can thousands of people be so unconsciously condescending and stupid and not realize it?)”¦
 On the riverfront, life and decay coexist...
Been reading McKibben’s Deep Economy and his chapter on “The Year of Eating Locally” provided a plethora of wonderful statistics. I’ve been speaking about urban gardening and food forests to friends and Nowtopia audiences for quite a while, and generally relying on the old stat that more than 40% of the fresh produce eaten by Americans at the end of WWII came from urban gardens. McKibben has documented several 21st century stats: Shanghai, the world’s biggest city, gets 60% of its vegetables and 90% of its milk and eggs from urban farms. A recent study estimates that London could produce 20% of the fruit and vegetables needed by its 10 million residents on the 10% of farmland left among its sprawl. Take it a step further to the idea of “One Lane for Food” and imagine if we start converting parts of asphalted roads, pointlessly wide, housing private autos on public lands, to linear farms”¦ add that to the existing networks of urban gardens and backyard orchards and we could start to approach a systematic urban food program that really could reinvent our lives. McKibben goes a lot further, debunking the notion that small urban farms are insufficiently productive, and shows the contrary, that they are more productive than large agribusiness fields farmed by lone machine drivers. Havana, Cuba is one of the best recent examples of a full-size city making the transition to local, sustainable, urban farming for its sustenance, but McKibben also shows how the rise of CSAs, farmer’s markets, and a panoply of new urban farming initiatives are reclaiming wrecked lands, restoring soil and water health, and becoming the starting point for a whole economic rejuvenation in many places, from Vermont to Wisconsin to Oregon (we certainly have experienced a version of the same in the Bay Area). Of course the key to this is labor intensive, small-scale farming. And “labor-intensive” might sound offensive to some, but if you consider the pointlessness and alienation and sheer ennui that define most jobs, you can put this New Food Agenda together with a critique of wage-labor to start shaping a real agenda for change”¦ no?
 Not for the wheelchair users! Barely for pedestrians and cyclists!
Four planes and 24 hours in transit but I made it without much trouble”¦ Kicking myself that I didn’t have my camera ready when we were soaring over the Amazon from Manaus to Belem, especially towards the end when an incredible view at dusk opened up to the west. Multiple giant rivers and vast interlocking estuarial canals, all heavily forested, all quite close to Belem, were framed by a thick layer of fluffy white clouds, a weird set of horizontal gray ellipse clouds in front of them, and then a high storm layer above it all, with the sun pouring through randomly in all directions. It was breathtaking! I had been assigned to a middle seat and thus, had put my bag away, out of reach, and couldn’t easily get my camera when I ended up in the window with the amazing view”¦ alas. You’ll just have to take my word for it!
Hanging around in Manaus for a couple of hours I met some other U.S. folks heading here, an environmental lawyer and a NGO staffer for Amazon Watch. I am now sitting in a school room at the Universidad Federal do Para, some Italians and Spaniards discussing how to properly write various documents that will be used to register the 80,000+ delegates who are already pouring into town. I come to the World Social Forum with curiosity and some modest excitement. I don’t know if this sprawling gathering aspires to invent a new form of global self-governance, but they still promote the slogan “another world is possible,” so it opens questions without necessarily providing an answer. The slogan may be better updated to a plural version to acknowledge the resistance to yet another hegemonic program for life, allowing instead for many other possible worlds”¦
My first take on Belem this time is very different from my memory, but then I haven’t yet been to the historic center where I have this vivid memory of watching torrential equatorial rains falling on ancient Mangueiras (mango trees) and hundreds of mangoes falling into the rushing black runoff, hungry kids scrambling to grab as many as they can and stuff them in their shorts for safe keeping (that was 20 years ago!). Today a taxi took me on a long ride across the city (from the plane it was really quite big, many dozens of 15-25 story buildings dotting the urbanscape from the air), which resembled many other rides I’ve had like this in the past into such cities as Mexico City, Sao Paolo, Rome or Naples”¦ a seedy, crumbling cityscape, lots of the trappings of modernity, but somehow already sliding beyond that into a post-prosperity seediness, many structures covered in tags and inartistic graffiti, others just succumbing to the endless humidity and tropical decay that relentlessly confronts any attempt at permanence here. I started reading China Mieville’s “Perdido Street Station” on my way here and the dark, hybrid alien/animal/human/machine life forms in New Crubazon City seemed weirdly premonitory for what I might find here in this odd outpost just below the equator, on the shores of the Amazon as it meets the southern Atlantic.
I’m a bit worried that it’ll be mostly a giant convention of leftists, assembling the usual litany of demands and spending a lot of time spinning wheels and waxing eloquently about injustice and so on, but if I’m lucky it’ll be a fantastic gathering full of endlessly challenging conversations that while not able to solve the problems of the world, might start framing better questions and better solutions too”¦ Reading also Bill McKibben’s “Deep Economy,” a smart book that goes head-on against Growth, dovetailing with the skype interview I did a couple of days ago with Fernanda and Mario from DecrescitaFeliz (Happy DeGrowth) somewhere on the Adriatic coast of Italy. The Nowtopian arguments also parallel and overlap this line of thought, of course, but it’s interesting to me how powerfully this new way of thinking seems to be bubbling up from below in many quarters. I’m extremely interested to find it here in Belem, and if I can’t, to add it to the mix as best I can”¦
I hope to have a good opportunity to do that in conversation with folks from India and England on the Global Charter for Labour. Peter Waterman is one of the conveners of this discussion, and he’s trying to push it beyond and outside the many other efforts that are likely to appear here, from the “Decent Work” campaign endorsed by the ISO, to the numerous trade union confederations (esp. from Global South) that tend to ignore or dismiss the vast numbers of precarious workers, ambulantes, etc. StreetNet is a group that has been organizing among the street vendors in India, so I’m excited to learn more about their thoughts and approach. Gratifyingly, some online comments on Peter’s pre-WSF documents were quite committed to challenging the regime of work as defined by Capitalism, and to make a new approach to global labour contingent on a serious reappraisal of what we do. Whew! I think I’ve found some people I can finally have a good conversation with!… it’s a bit odd that I’m such a loner, only organizationally affiliated (with the Global Commons Foundation) as a flag of convenience, but I hope that doesn’t leave me in a bad position in these conversations. Waterman seemed to know what I’ve been up to all these years, so I think I’ll get a good chance to partake”¦
or maybe not! Having arrived and had a quick look at the overwhelming program booklet, with over 2000 events and workshops, I will be surprised if any focused conversation really happens here… but anyway, it’s still good to be here…
Today I walked around a bunch and took photos to get a sense of the place… here’s a gallery:
 Equatorial rains pour down on Belem, this view from my balcony.
 The Workers' Party of President Lula has put these up around town.
 19th century low-rise structures, often covered in graffiti, sit side by side with typical highrise apartments.
 The old harbor in Belem, as the rain is starting again.
 Dinner time at the Harbor!
 The street's residents demand signalization!
On my walk around town today I came upon this charming neighborhood where the neighbors are organizing for a traffic signal… much more to come on streets and street conditions here in Belem in a later post at the sf.streetsblog.org site… and much more to come here in the next days about the World Social Forum, the chaos and the excitement, the politics and the confusion…
I’ve been working on other things, thus dropped the blog-ball a bit lately… one reason is I’ve actually been employed to write 3 blog posts a month over at sf.streetsblog.org, so that’ll get in the way of putting things here. (The Jane Martin piece was the first one.) I agreed that I might re-post some things here after two weeks, but here’s the latest one I did for them on depaving and history.
The REALLY BIG NEWS is that the long-promised Shaping San Francisco wiki is up and running and ready to visit! It’s at FoundSF.org, which we’ve renamed it, in light of our new partnership (not quite signed yet) with the San Francisco Museum and Historical Society. I also posted the Spring Bike Tour calendar in case anyone is waiting for that. And I’m trying to finalize the March-May Talks series, overcoming a number of glitches… will post that here soon.
I’m getting out of town this Friday, heading to Belem, Brazil for the World Social Forum, and when I get back on Feb. 4, I will only get up again the next morning to head to Los Angeles where I have a bunch of Nowtopia appearances lined up til I finally come home late on Feb. 9.
Meanwhile, the weather here in San Francisco, while I was expecting to be indoors continuously, has been eerily summer-like. Here’s some shots I took at random last Saturday, late in the day, as I rode over to the lower Haight. First a couple of shots of Dolores Park, nowadays chock full of young hipsters whenever the weather is suitable…
 Dolores Park, January 17 09, wintery light, summery air, just north of 19th Street.
 Winter light pours over Liberty Hill onto sunbathing denizens on the slopes above 19th Street in Dolores Park, Jan. 17, 2009.
After that I ended up over at Alamo Square and took this iconic photo, happily with humans in it for a change, followed by a strange look at City Hall due to the new architectural landmarks that sprouted behind it in the past few years.
 The most typical SF photo... Alamo Square towards Downtown.
 SF City Hall from Fulton Street next to Alamo Square. Federal Bldg to right and new turquoise hotel at 5th and Howard to left.
Another task on my plate is to finish a rewrite on an article I’ve been collaborating with Francesca on, for Antipode magazine, called “Nowtopia: Strategic Exodus?” The new writing has to address the “virtual spine of the commons” as I dubbed it in the book, the net, but also networking more broadly. On my way to the World Social Forum, I’m acutely aware of what an abundance of writing and thinking is going on covering the broad topic of networking politics. A couple of interesting articles I read were Social Movements 2.0 by Brendan Smith, Tim Costello & Jeremy Brecher, and The Alternative’s Alternative by Evgeny Morozov. Smith and Costello spoke at a recent Networking Politics conference I attended at Berkeley, and I really appreciated their argument, most of which is reprised in this piece at the Nation. A key to their ambivalent embrace of new online networks is that so far, it’s easy enough to get huge numbers of people to sign petitions and donate money, but really rare to translate such behaviors “into solidarity built on trust and a willingness to take economic or physical risk on another’s behalf.”
“We’re drawing closer to the point where the majority of online tools are so simple that technical experts are beginning to fade into the background. The web is no longer the exclusive dominion of the young and highly educated, and as this trend continues it will allow social movements to cheaply and easily reach out to increasingly diverse constituencies.”
But along with these transformations they correctly note that existing organizations, often quite hierarchical and top-down, will have to cede control to self-organizing individuals. I recall ten years ago when I was working on the first iteration of the ILWU website (they later hired some big firm to do a revamp) there was a great deal of confusion and nervousness about how to present the union on-line. At the time some union leaders were quite resistant to even including the union’s constitution on line, and to this day, they are hostile to an open forum where members can speak to each other directly on the union’s official site. As the authors put it: “The destruction of hierarchies online means that top-down organizations will face increasing pressure from members to permit more rank-and-file debate and input. This is a healthy process and a long time in coming… Organizations that resist this trend will become increasingly irrelevant online and offline.”
Continue reading The Webs We Weave
|
Hidden San Francisco 2nd EDITION!

NEW 2nd EDITION NOW AVAILABLE! Buy one here (Pluto Press, Spring 2025)
|